Riddell SpeedFlex vs. Schutt Vengeance Pro LTD II – Football Helmet Comparison

Design and Construction

The Riddell SpeedFlex features a cutting-edge design that integrates modern safety advancements with a recognizable and innovative look. Its standout element is the flexible front panel, part of the Flex System, which incorporates flexibility into the shell, facemask, and clips to better absorb impact forces. Built with a polycarbonate shell, it presents a futuristic aesthetic while prioritizing player safety. In contrast, the Schutt Vengeance Pro LTD II maintains a more traditional helmet design with its mohawk-inspired, low-profile Vengeance shell. While its shell is also made of durable polycarbonate, Schutt focuses on subtle performance upgrades like better stabilization and interior refinement rather than a full redesign.

Impact Protection Technology

The SpeedFlex utilizes Riddell’s patented Side Impact Protection (PISP) and a composite energy management system that distributes force across different padding zones. It also includes an inflatable liner to help provide a personalized fit that contributes to both protection and comfort. Meanwhile, the Vengeance Pro LTD II employs a single-layer black TPU cushioning system for impact absorption, enhanced by a molded EVA frontal pad. It also introduces the Helmet Stabilization System (HSS), which adds internal support to keep the helmet securely in place during play, offering a reliable defense against rotational forces.

Fit and Comfort

In terms of fit, the SpeedFlex stands out with its inflatable liner and 1" jaw pads, allowing players to fine-tune the helmet’s fit using a Riddell inflator pump. This enables a customized, snug feel, though it requires careful handling and routine maintenance to avoid damaging the liner. The Schutt Vengeance Pro LTD II simplifies the process with non-inflatable components, using Surefit lateral air liners and velcro-secured 1/2" jaw pads. While it doesn't offer the same precision fit as an inflatable system, it reduces the chances of user error and still delivers a secure, comfortable fit.

Facemask and Chinstrap

Both helmets offer solid options in facemask compatibility and chinstrap quality. The SpeedFlex comes with a white soft cup Cam-Loc chinstrap that is easy to adjust and provides good retention. It also features quick-release facemask attachments, although facemasks must be purchased separately. The Vengeance Pro LTD II includes a soft cup chinstrap as well, though the color may vary. It uses Schutt’s twist-release nose bumper, which simplifies the facemask attachment process. While both helmets allow for customization, the SpeedFlex gives slightly more flexibility in facemask styles, while the Vengeance Pro LTD II prioritizes ease of use.

Weight and Feel

Weighing in at approximately 3.45 pounds, the SpeedFlex provides a solid, well-balanced feel that many players trust at all levels of play. It has a performance-oriented build with robust padding and structural design. On the other hand, the Vengeance Pro LTD II is noticeably lighter at around 2.65 pounds, giving it an edge in terms of agility and overall comfort. This makes it particularly appealing to players who value a lighter helmet without sacrificing essential protective features.

Safety Ratings and Maintenance

Both helmets hold Virginia Tech’s top 5-star safety rating, affirming their status among the safest options available. The SpeedFlex was groundbreaking in 2014, becoming the first helmet to score under 0.2 in STAR value. However, its inflatable liner system requires careful maintenance — incorrect inflation can damage the liner and void the warranty. In contrast, the Vengeance Pro LTD II uses a non-inflatable system, eliminating the need for specialized equipment and reducing maintenance concerns, which could be a practical advantage for some players and teams.

Summary

The Riddell SpeedFlex is ideal for players looking for an advanced helmet with a high level of fit customization and superior side-impact protection. Its futuristic design and proven safety performance make it a popular choice among elite athletes. The Schutt Vengeance Pro LTD II, while more traditional in appearance, offers an excellent lightweight alternative with reliable comfort and simplified maintenance. It's a great option for players who want dependable protection with less complexity in fit and upkeep.